Images and Words: An Online History of Photography

Introduction | Contents | Foreword | Testing

Focal PressRobert Hirsch Exploring Color Photography, Fifth edition (Focal Press, 2011)
Chapter: 2 Section: 7
Buy this book

Previous | Next

2.7. Additive Screen Processes

In 1869 Louis Ducos du Hauron, a French scientist, published Les Couleurs en photographie – solution du problème, which anticipated many of the theoretical frameworks for making analog color photographs. Among his proposed solutions was one in which the additive theory could be applied in a manner that did not require the complicated separation process that Maxwell devised. Ducos Du Hauron speculated that a screen ruled with fine lines in the three primary colors would act as a filter to produce a color photograph with a single exposure instead of the theoretical three needed in Maxwell’s experiment ). At the time, he photographed each scene through green, orange, and violet filters (at the time considered the primary colors of light), then printed his three exposures on thin sheets of bichromated gelatin containing carbon pigments of red, blue, and yellow— the complementary colors. When the three positives (transparencies) were superimposed, a full-color photograph resulted. Simultaneously, Charles Cros independently demonstrated how color images could be made using three-color separation negatives/positives, confirming the path that could be followed for a practical color process to evolve. [1|2|7|1453]

 
Louis Ducos du Hauron
Still life with rooster
1869-1879 (ca)
Color print, dye imbibition process
16.4 x 19.8 cm
 
George Eastman House
Record Id: 1982:1568:0001FP
 
LL/35661
 
 
Additional examples:
 
Checklist
LL/35661 LL/38163 

To simplify the process, in the first decade of the twentieth century, companies such as Sanger Shepherd in England began to manufacture “Repeating Back” attachments, which allowed the photographer to make separate exposures of a static subject – each time through a different colored filter – that were later combined to form a single color image. This was followed by “One-Shot” cameras that used black-and-white plates to simultaneously make three exposures of the same subject through three separate color filters. This method was also employed for the Lumiere Brothers Trichromie (a.k.a. Trichrome) process. Improvements followed, and these triple-exposure cameras were used for advertising and portrait work until the advent of multi-layered films like Kodachrome, Agfacolor, and Kodacolor. [1|2|7|1454]

2.8. Joly Color

In 1894 John Joly, a Dublin physicist, patented the first linescreen process for additive color photographs, based on Louis Ducos du Hauron’s concept. In this process, a glass screen with transparent ruled lines of red, green, and blue, about two hundred lines per inch, was placed against the emulsion of an orthochromatic (not sensitive to red light) plate. The exposure was made and the screen removed. The plate was processed and contact printed on another plate to make a positive black-andwhite transparency which was placed in exact register with the same screen used to make the exposure. The final result was a limited-color photographic transparency that was viewed by transmitted light. Introduced in 1896 as the Joly Color process, this method enjoyed only a brief success. It was expensive and the available emulsions still were not sensitive to the full range of the spectrum, thus the final image was not able to achieve the look of “natural” color. However, Joly’s work indicated that the additive screen process had the potential to become a commercially viable way of making color photographs. [1|2|8|1455]

 
Unknown photographer (Irish)
Stuffed Birds
1895 (ca)
Joly Color
George Eastman House
Courtesy of George Eastman House, Rochester, NY.
 
Joly Color, the first commercial line-screen process for additive color photographs, was introduced to the public in 1896. Although it had only limited success, it indicated the additive method could become a commercially viable way for making color photographs.
 
LL/41541
 
 
Additional examples:
 
Checklist
LL/41541 LL/41542 


Autochromes: Invention
View exhibition
Title | Lightbox | Checklist
Autochromes: Introduction
View exhibition
Title | Lightbox | Checklist

2.9. Autochrome

In Lyons, France, Auguste and Louis Lumière, the inventors of the first practical motion picture projector, patented a major breakthrough in the making of color photographs in 1904. The Autochrome Lumière was the first commercially viable and extensively used color photographic process. Introduced to the market in 1907, it remained in production until 1935. Autochrome was a reversal process, which produced one unique image—a positive transparency on a glass support that was viewed by projection or through a transmitted light source. [1|2|9|1456]

 
Lumière Brothers
M. Louis Lumiere in 1907: photograph taken at the time he developed the Autochrome process
1935, 9 November
Magazine page, printed reproduction from an Autochrome glass plate - plaques Autochrome
Private collection of Nadia Valla
© L'Illustration
 
1895-1935, the 40st anniversary of the cinematograph: 14 pages of articles and documents on the Lumière brothers life and works and on the evolution of the cinema.
 
The test tubes in the image hold the the dyes from which were chosen those used to color the starch grain filterlettes sprinkled on to a sticky varnish, and the carbon black powder used to fill in the gaps left after the grains were crushed flat in a rolling mill. [William R. Alschuler, pers. Comm. 30 Dec 2009]
 
LL/13541
 
 
Additional examples:
 
Checklist
LL/13541 LL/8886 LL/8885 
LL/8892 LL/8878 LL/8879 
LL/41562 LL/8863 


Autochromes: Technique
View exhibition
Title | Lightbox | Checklist

An Autochrome plate was produced as follows: (1) a glass support was covered with an initial layer of varnish that remained tacky; (2) the color screen layer, composed of potato starch grains dyed orange-red, green, and violet-blue, was dusted onto the sticky varnish; (3) a fine carbon black powder was used to fill remaining gaps between the grains, and the layers were then pressed flat in a rolling press; (4) a second varnish was applied to protect the starch grains from moisture; (5) a photosensitive layer of silver gelatin emulsion was then applied ; panchromatic emulsion, which greatly extended the accuracy of recording the full range of the visible spectrum, became the emulsion of choice once it became commercially available in 1906; (6) after exposure and processing, the manufacturer recommended a final coat of varnish to further protect the plate before a cover glass was applied to preserve the entire color image. [1|2|9|1457]

 
Anon.
Microphotography of the Autochrome trichromatic selection mosaic, made of dyed potato starch grains (7000 grains / mm2)
n.d.
Microphotograph
Institut Lumière (The Lumiere Institute)
© Institut Lumière
 
LL/8865
 
 
Additional examples:
 
Checklist
LL/8865 LL/9484 

To maintain a proper color balance, a deep yellow filter was placed in front of the camera lens. The exposure was made with the plate’s filter layer pointed toward the lens, so that the dyed potato starch acted as tiny filters. After development, the plate was re-exposed to light, and finally redeveloped to form a positive transparency made up of tiny dots of the primary colors. The Autochrome was a pioneering method of utilizing the principles articulated by Ducos du Hauron and Charles Cros in which the eye mixed the colors, in a fashion much like George Seurat’s pointillist painting Sunday Afternoon on the Island of La Grande Jatte (1884 – 1886), to make a color-positive image. Alfred Stieglitz sang its praises in Camera Work, Number 20, October 1907: “Color photography is an accomplished fact. The seemingly everlasting question whether color would ever be within the reach of the photographer has been definitely answered … The possibilities of the process seem to be unlimited … In short, soon the world will be color-mad, and Lumière will be responsible.” [1|2|9|1458]

 
Anon.
"Color photography for all" - Booklet cover
1911
Book cover
Private collection of Nadia Valla
© Nadia Valla
 
LL/8873
 
 

Used from 1907 to 1935, Autochrome did have its limitations. Since the light had to travel through the potato starch grains and the yellow filter on the front of the lens, exposure times were much longer than with the black-and-white films of the day. In the additive processes, it was not uncommon for 75 percent or more of the light to be absorbed by this combination of filters before reaching the emulsion. Suggested starting exposure time was between 1/5 of a second and 1 second at f/4 in direct sunlight at midday in the summer and six times longer on a cloudy day, although over time there were many suggestions on how to increase its sensitivity. The randomly applied potato grains tended to bunch up, creating blobs of color. Also, Autochromes that were not lantern projected could be difficult to see and were sometimes placed in specially designed viewers called diascopes. When they were regularly marketed in New York (ca. 1910), a box of four 3 1/4 × 4-inch plates cost $1.20 and a box of 7 × 14-inch plates sold for $7.50, making them pricey for an average working person. [1|2|9|1459]

 
Anon.
Agenda lumière - advertisement
n.d.
Advert
Private collection of Nadia Valla
© Nadia Valla
 
LL/8870
 
 
Additional examples:
 
Checklist
LL/8870 LL/8867 LL/9039 
LL/41543 


Autochromes: Amateurs
View exhibition
Title | Lightbox | Checklist

The advantages of this process, however, were numerous. Autochromes could be used in any regular plate camera with the addition of a special yellow-orange filter; the image was made in one exposure, not in three; although pricey, the cost was not overly prohibitive; it gave serious amateurs much easier access to color; and while the colors were not accurate by today’s standards, they did produce a warm, soft, and inviting pastel image that people considered to be quite pleasing. [1|2|9|1460]

 
Fred Payne Clatworthy
Sioux Indian Group
1927
Autochrome
5 × 7 ins
 
Private collection of Mark Jacobs
Courtesy of Mark Jacobs Collection.
 
Fred Payne Clatworthy, the favorite independent autochromist of National Geographic ’s illustrations editor Franklin Fisher, specialized in scenic Autochromes of the American West. Clatworthy owned and operated a photo studio in Rocky Mountain National Park. The original National Geographic (Vol. LIII, June 1928) caption for this image reads,
 
“No other tribe resisted the oncoming tide of the white man’s civilization with more determination than the brave and aggressive Sioux. A well-equipped people, both physically and mentally, they were for many years monarchs of the country that is now Minnesota, the Dakotas, and Montana. The ancestors of some of the chiefs pictured here planned and executed the campaign in which Custer’s immortal band perished.”
 
LL/41545
 
 
Additional examples:
 
Checklist
LL/41545 LL/8959 LL/8960 
LL/8957 LL/8958 LL/8961 
LL/8962 LL/9163 


Autochromes and Autochromists of WWI
View exhibition
Title | Lightbox | Checklist
Autochromes: From around the world
View exhibition
Title | Lightbox | Checklist
Autochromes: National Geographic
View exhibition
Title | Lightbox | Checklist

World War I was the first major conflict to be covered by color photography. Autochromes became the basis for publications such as L’Histoire illustrée de la guerre de 1914. By the end of World War I, magazines such as National Geographic were using Autochromes to make color reproductions for the first time in their publications. Between 1914 and 1938, National Geographic published a reported 2,355 Autochromes, more than any other journal, thus taking a leadership role in bringing the “realism” of color photography into mass circulation. Autochrome was the first color process to get beyond the novelty stage and to become successful in the market place. It cracked a major aesthetic barrier because it was taken seriously for its picture-making potentialities. This enabled photographers to begin to explore the visual possibilities of making meaningful color photographs for ambitious projects such as Albert Kahn’s Archives of the Planet . Between 1909 and 1931, the French banker financed photographic teams who visited over 50 countries and amassed some 72,000 Autochrome plates that documented the diversity of the human condition in color, not just as ethnography or reportage but also for the purpose of inspiring education and universal peace. 1 [1|2|9|1461]

 
Jean-Baptiste Tournassoud
Alpine infantry at camp
1914 (ca)
Autochrome Lumière
13 x 18 cm
 
Institut Lumière (The Lumiere Institute)
© Coll. Institut Lumière, Lyon - France / info@tournassoud.org
 
LL/8033
 
 
Additional examples:
 
Checklist
LL/8033 LL/8030 LL/9105 
LL/6237 LL/9106 LL/9101 
LL/9102 LL/41544 

2.10. Finlay Colour Process and Paget Dry Plate

Other additive screen processes followed on the heels of Autochrome. In 1906 Clare L. Finlay of England patented a process that was introduced in 1908 as the Thames Colour Screen. Made up in a precise checkerboard fashion of red, green, and blue elements, rather than the random mosaic pattern used in Autochrome, this separate screen could be used with any type of panchromatic film or plate to make a color photograph. The Thames Colour Plate, which combined an integral screen with the emulsion to form a single plate, was released in 1909. Both of these processes were abandoned after World War I, but improved versions were marketed under the name of Finlay Colour in 1929 and 1931. The Finlay Colour processes were to be the major rivals to Dufaycolor until the introduction of subtractive-process materials in the mid-1930s. [1|2|10|1462]

 
Unidentified photographer (British)
[Youth Group by Ocean]
1913 (ca)
Thames plate
4 x 5 ins
 
Private collection of Mark Jacobs
Courtesy of Mark Jacobs Collection.
 
The Thames Colour Plate, which combined the Thames Colour Screen with emulsion into one unit, was an additive screen process used from 1909 until about 1918. The process was later improved and rereleased as Finlay Colour.
 
LL/41546
 
 
Additional examples:
 
Checklist
LL/41546 LL/41547 LL/41637 
LL/41638 LL/41639 LL/41640 
LL/41641 LL/41642 LL/41643 

In 1912 G.S. Whitfield also obtained a patent for screenplates that were marketed by the Paget Dry Plate Company. Renamed Duplex in 1920, the process was discontinued few years later. [1|2|10|1463]

2.11. Dufaycolor

From about 1909 to 1914, the French firm of Louis Dufay made the Dioptichrome Plate to compete with the Autochrome. Although withdrawn from production, the process later was improved and renamed Dufaycolor when it was introduced as a ciné film in 1932. Soon produced as both cut-sheet and roll film, thus making it simple to use, Dufaycolor gave wider public access to color photography. The process became popular, especially in the UK, because it was faster (more light sensitive) than Autochrome and did not require any additional optical device to form a viewable image. Also, some people preferred the structure of its screen, which was a mosaic of alternating blue-dye and green-dye squares that were crossed at right angles by a pattern of parallel red-dye lines. This design offered greater color accuracy and a faster emulsion; by the mid-1930s exposures of f/8 at 1/25 of a second on a sunny day were possible, but the projected image was subdued and flawed by the conspicuous mosaic pattern. Dufaycolor was marketed until the late 1940s. By this time, the quest for an easier-to-use process that would provide more realistic and natural colors brought about technical discoveries that would eventually make the additive screen processes commercially obsolete. However, various film-based versions of Autochrome, including Filmcolor (1931), Lumicolor (1933), and Atlicolor (1952), were made into the mid-1950s. [1|2|11|1464]

 
Unidentified photographer (British)
USSR Pavilion, Paris
1938
Dufaycolor
3 1/2 x 2 3/8 ins
 
Private collection of Mark Jacobs
Courtesy of Mark Jacobs Collection.
 
Dufaycolor, introduced in the 1930s, became the most popular of the additive screen processes because it was faster, had an improved screen that provided more realistic color, and, since it was film rather than plates, was easier to use.
 
LL/41548
 
 

2.12. Polachrome

Between 1983 and 2002 Polaroid (see Diffusion-Transfer Process later in this chapter) marketed Polachrome, an instant 35mm color slide film that could be used in any 35mm camera, which was based on additive-color, line-screen, positive-transparency film similar to Joly Color. The film was inserted with an individual chemical pod into a small tabletop Polaroid AutoProcessor for processing. Although it was convenient, it never achieved widespread use due to issues of color accuracy and because the line-screen became highly visible when the image was projected or enlarged. [1|2|12|1465]

2.13. Additive Equipment - Additive Enlargers

Today the additive method is occasionally employed in color printmaking. It is in limited use because additive enlarger systems are more complex and expensive. To make a full color print with the additive process, the enlarger is used to make three separate exposures, one through each of the three primary-colored filters. The blue filter is used first and controls the amount of blue in the print, next the green filter is used for the green content, and last is the red filter. Some people prefer this additive technique, also known as tricolor printing, because it is relatively easy to make adjustments in the filter pack, with each filter controlling its own color. [1|2|13|1466]

2.14. Digital Enlargers

A major change in additive color printing is the use of digital enlargers in professional photography labs that continue to make chemical prints on silver halide paper (light-sensitive compounds in paper and film). Instead of the older bulb-based printers, this combination of chemical-based color printing and digital imaging relies on rapid bursts of laser light in three colors — red, green, and blue — to expose the photographic paper. The laser light is bounced off a rotating six-sided mirror that reflects the light dots onto the paper. As the mirror turns, it draws a line across the paper in light, making extremely sharp images. These digital enlargers have the additional advantage of high-speed scanners and the ability to work from a digital file, which allows each image to be analyzed by software that adjusts color, contrast, and exposure as needed. It also has facial recognition software for smoothing facial features so that not every skin pore is sharply apparent. Other systems, such as Durst Lambda and LightJet, use LED light printers instead of lasers. [1|2|14|1467]

2.15. Television

The additive system is the ideal vehicle for color television since the set creates and then emits the light-forming picture. The cathode ray tube (CRT) in color television has three electron guns, each corresponding to one of the additive primaries. These guns stimulate red, green, or blue phosphors on the screen to create different combinations of the three primaries. This creates all the colors that form the images we see on the television set. Liquid crystal display (LCD) and plasma (a type of gas) flat-screen televisions use the same RGB concept to have pixels (picture element) form the color image. A typical 8-bit LCD or plasma television utilizes a 256 red × 256 green × 256 blue subpixel depth to deliver 16,777,216 color combinations. [1|2|15|1468]

2.16. The Subtractive Method

Louis Ducos du Hauron not only proposed a method for making color photographs with the additive process in Les Couleurs en photographie , he also suggested a method for making color photographs using the subtractive process. [1|2|16|1469]

The subtractive process operates by removing certain colors from white light while allowing others to pass. The modern subtractive primaries (cyan, magenta, and yellow) are the complementary colors of the three additive primaries (red, green, and blue). When white light is passed through one of the subtractive-colored filters it transmits two of the primaries and absorbs (subtracts) the other. Individually, each subtractive filter transmits two-thirds of the spectrum while blocking one-third of it. For example, a magenta filter passes red and blue but blocks green. When two filters are superimposed, they subtract two primaries and transmit one. Magenta and yellow filters block green and blue, allowing red to pass. When all three subtractive primaries overlap in equal amounts, they block all the wavelengths and produce black. When mixed in varying proportions, they are capable of making almost any color. The advantages of the subtractive method over the additive process are twofold: It makes possible a full-color reproduction on paper and dispenses with the prior need for expensive and cumbersome viewing equipment. [1|2|16|1470]

 
Anon.
The subtractive process
n.d.
Private collection of Robert Hirsch
The subtractive process allows almost any color to be formed by removing certain colors from white light while permitting other colors to pass. The subtractive primary colors in photography are cyan, magenta, and yellow. They are the complementary colors of the additive primaries: red, green, and blue. Black is formed when equal amounts of all three of the subtractive primaries overlap.
 
LL/41549
 
 

2.17. Primary Pigment Colors

When working with pigments – as in painting – instead of light, the colors are also formed subtractively. The different colors of pigments absorb certain wavelengths of light and reflect others back for us to see. However, there is a major distinction between the primary colors of pigment and those of light, as painters generally use red, blue, and yellow for their primary colors. These colors cannot be mixed from any other colors and in theory are used to make all other colors, with the assistance of black-and-white. For example, red and yellow make orange, red and blue make purple, and blue and yellow make green. Green, an additive primary, is not a primary color in paint because it must be made from two colors: blue and yellow. In practice, it is necessary to use secondary and intermediate colors when mixing other colors, such as green and violet, because artist’s pigment is not “pure color.” The wavelengths of its minor components are different from the dominant wavelength and therefore affect the color produced. [1|2|17|1471]

2.18. The Subtractive Assembly Process: Heliography

In Ducos du Hauron’s patented subtractive method, known as Heliochromy, three negatives were made behind separate filters of violet, green, and orange-red (the current modern subtractive filters had not yet been established). From these negatives, positives were made and assembled in register to create the final print, known as a Heliochrome. These positives contained carbon pigments of blue, red, and yellow, which Ducos du Hauron believed to be the complementary colors of the filters that were used to form the colors in the original exposure. Color prints or transparencies could be made with the assembly process, depending on whether the carbon transparencies were attached onto an opaque or transparent support. One of the first commercial subtractive assembly processes was the bichromated gelatin glue process, which was known as Trichromie and was patented by the Lumière Brothers in 1895. The assembly process is the principle used in the carbro process (see below). [1|2|18|1472]


 
FOOTNOTES
  1. David Okuefuna, The Dawn of the Color Photograph: Albert Kahn’s Archives of the Planet (Princeton, NJ and Oxford: Princeton University Press, 2008), p. 7.
     

 

Sections

 2.1The First Color Photographs: Applied Color Processes 2.2Direct Color Process: First Experiments
 2.3The Hillotype Controversy 2.4The Additive Theory: First Photographic Image in Color
 2.5Maxwell’s Projection Process 2.6Direct Interference Method of Gabriel Lippmann
=> 2.7Additive Screen Processes 2.8Joly Color
 2.9Autochrome 2.10Finlay Colour Process and Paget Dry Plate
 2.11Dufaycolor 2.12Polachrome
 2.13Additive Equipment - Additive Enlargers 2.14Digital Enlargers
 2.15Television 2.16The Subtractive Method
 2.17Primary Pigment Colors 2.18The Subtractive Assembly Process: Heliography
 2.19The Kromskop Triple Camera and Kromskop Viewer 2.20Carbro Process
 2.21Color Halftones 2.22Dye-Imbibition Process/Dye Transfer Process
 2.23Subtractive Film and Chromogenic Development 2.24The Kodachrome Process
 2.25Chromogenic Transparency Film 2.26Chromogenic Negative Film
 2.27C-41: Chromogenic Negative Development 2.28Additional Color Processes - Silver Dye-Bleach/Dye-Destruction Process
 2.29Internal Dye Diffusion-Transfer Process 2.30The Polaroid Process: Diffusion-Transfer
 2.31Color Gains Acceptance in the Art World 2.32Amateur Systems Propel the Use of Color
 2.33Digital Imaging 2.34The Birth of Computing
 2.35The 1960s: Art in the Research Lab 2.36The 1970s and 1980s: Computers Get Personal
 2.37Digital Imaging Enters the Mainstream  

Previous | Next

Parts of this text are © Focal Press, Inc. All rights reserved.
Images on this webpage may or may not be included in the published work.
Copyright on Luminous-lint
Please report factual errors as soon as possible to alan@luminous-lint.com along with the numbers that end each paragraph.
We would like to say a grateful thanks to all the private collectors, dealers, gallerists, photo-curators and photo-historians who have made this website possible by providing images and information.
This website is dedicated to those that share for the benefit of all - Thank you.